In Place/out of Place: Geography, Ideology, and Transgression
Minnesota Archive Editions ed.
University of Minnesota Press
What is the relationship between place and behaviour? In this volume, Cresswell examines this question via "transgressive acts" that are judged as inappropriate not only because they are committed by marginalized groups but also because of where they occur. This text seeks to illustrate the ways in which the idea of geographical deviance is used as an ideological tool to maintain an established order. Cresswell looks at graffiti in New York City, the attempts by various "hippie" groups to hold a free festival at Stonehenge during the summer solstices of 1984-86, and the Greenham Common Women's Peace Camp in Berkshire. In each of the cases described, the groups involved were designated as out of place both by the media and by politicians, whose descriptions included an array of images such as dirt, disease, madness, and foreignness. Cresswell argues that space and place are key factors in the definition of deviance and, conversely, that space and place are used to construct notions of order and propriety. In addition, whereas ideological concepts being expressed about what is good, just, and appropriate often are delineated geographically, the transgression of these delineations reveals the normally hidden relationships between place and ideology - in other words, the "out-of-place" serves to highlights and define the "in-place". By looking at the transgressions of the marginalized, Crewell argues, we can gain a novel perspective on the normal" and "taken-for-granted" expectations of everyday life.